Every law firm SEO company will tell you they get results. Most will show you a chart with a line going up. Very few will let you check whether that line belongs to a client who’s still with them.
Choosing badly is expensive twice over — you lose the retainer, and you lose the twelve months the work would have compounded. Here’s how to evaluate a law firm SEO company properly, including the questions that make weak ones uncomfortable.
First: do you need a legal specialist?
Usually yes, and for three specific reasons rather than as a matter of principle.
Bar advertising rules. Attorney marketing is regulated. Illinois Rules of Professional Conduct 7.1 through 7.5 govern what you can claim, how you describe specialization, and what disclaimers appear where. An agency that has never read them will happily write you a page that violates them, and it’s your license, not theirs.
Legal search behavior is distinctive. Someone searching “criminal defense attorney near me” at 2am is in a different state of mind from someone comparing software vendors. The content, the page structure and the calls to action all need to reflect urgency, discretion and trust.
It’s a YMYL category. Google treats legal content as “Your Money or Your Life” and holds it to higher standards for expertise and trustworthiness. Generic content written by someone who has never worked with a firm tends to underperform badly here.
That said — a strong generalist who takes the time to learn your practice area beats a “legal SEO specialist” running a template across two hundred firms. Specialization is a signal, not a guarantee.
The conflict nobody mentions
Ask whether the agency works with your direct competitors.
Plenty of legal SEO companies sign multiple firms in the same practice area in the same city. They cannot get all of you to position one. Somebody is paying to lose, and the agency is fine either way because both retainers clear.
Ask directly: do you have exclusivity in my practice area and market, and will you put it in writing? The answer tells you a lot, whichever way it goes.
Seven questions worth asking
1. “Show me a client you’ve had for more than two years.”
Anyone can show a good first six months. Long retention means the work kept paying. Short client lists with impressive early numbers often mean churn.
2. “Which specific searches will you target, and what’s the monthly volume?”
You want named keywords with real numbers, not “we’ll optimize your site.” Be alert to agencies that report rankings for phrases nobody searches — ranking #1 for “aggressive criminal defense lawyer Chicago Illinois affordable” is easy and worthless.
3. “Who’s above me now, and what would it take to pass them?”
This forces them to have actually looked at your market before pitching. A good answer includes roughly how far ahead those competitors are and how long closing the gap takes.
4. “Who writes the content, and do they understand legal advertising rules?”
Find out whether it’s a legal writer, a generalist, or an AI draft nobody edits. Ask to see a practice-area page they’ve written. You’ll know within a paragraph.
5. “How do you build links?”
Legitimate: legal directories, bar associations, local sponsorships, press, genuinely useful content that earns citations. Dangerous: bulk guest posts, private blog networks, anything sold by volume. Paid links violate Google’s guidelines and can get you penalized, and the agency will not be the one explaining that to your partners.
6. “What does reporting look like, and does it connect to cases?”
Rankings and traffic are inputs. Signed cases are the output. Ask whether they track calls and form fills to source, and whether they’ll help you tie those to matters. If reporting stops at “impressions are up,” you’ll never know if it worked.
7. “What happens if I leave?”
Ask who owns the website, the content, the Google Business Profile and the analytics accounts. Some agencies build on proprietary platforms you cannot take with you — leaving means starting from zero. Get ownership in writing before you start, not when you’re trying to go.
Red flags
- Guaranteed #1 rankings. Nobody controls Google’s results. This is either a lie or a plan to rank you for something meaningless.
- Long lock-in with no exit. Twelve months is reasonable given how SEO compounds. Twelve months with no performance clause and no way out is a trap.
- Vagueness about who does the work. Ask where your account manager sits and who writes the content.
- Pricing that’s an outlier in either direction. Far below market usually means automation. Far above should come with a clear reason.
- No questions about your practice. An agency that pitches without asking which case types you actually want more of is selling a package, not a strategy.
- Reporting you can’t verify. You should have direct login access to your own Analytics and Search Console — not screenshots.
What good looks like in the first 90 days
A competent engagement is legible early, even before rankings move:
- Weeks 1–2: technical audit, access to your properties, baseline metrics recorded. You should know exactly where you’re starting.
- Weeks 3–6: technical fixes shipped, Google Business Profile optimized, practice-area page architecture agreed.
- Weeks 7–12: content publishing on a schedule, citations cleaned up, early movement on lower-competition and branded terms.
You should not be waiting until month six to see evidence that work is happening. Rankings take time; activity doesn’t.
What it should cost
Law firm SEO typically runs $2,500 – $10,000 per month, and the spread is mostly about market competitiveness. A family law practice in a smaller market sits at the bottom; personal injury in Chicago sits at the top, because the competitors are spending that and a single case can justify a year of fees.
Work out what a signed case is worth to you before you evaluate any proposal. If your average matter is worth $8,000 and SEO costs $3,000 a month, you need roughly five additional cases a year to break even. That’s the calculation that tells you whether a quote is expensive — not the number by itself.
We covered this in more detail in how much SEO costs.
How to run the decision
Talk to three agencies, not one. Give each the same brief so the proposals are comparable. Ask all seven questions above and note who answers directly and who deflects.
Then pick on two things: whether their plan is specific to your firm, and whether you’d want to talk to this person every month for a year. Specificity beats polish, and you will be living with the relationship.
Talk to us — or don’t, and use this anyway
We build and run SEO for law firms, so we’re one of the companies you’d be evaluating. Fair enough to weigh this accordingly.
What we’ll actually do if you get in touch: look at your site and the firms currently outranking you, and tell you what it would take — including when the honest answer is that your bottleneck is intake, not traffic. Then you can take that assessment to whoever you like.
Request a free site audit, or call or text 888-821-4161. Based in Chicago, working with firms nationwide.
About the author
Mitch Furman
Founder, Baba Yaga Digital Marketing · Chicago criminal defense attorney
Admitted to the Illinois bar in 2000 · Graduate of The John Marshall Law School · Criminal and DUI defense in Cook, DuPage, Will, Kankakee and Lake Counties
Mitch built and runs the search marketing for his own law practice and travel brand, and now does the same for law firms, local service businesses and brands across the United States — on WordPress, Elementor Pro, Rank Math, Search Console, GA4 and Google Ads. Everything we recommend has been tested on our own sites first.